T10T: Highest Rated TBR Titles


Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly blog meme hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl.

This week’s prompt was actually Books I Disliked But I’m Glad I Read, but I wanted to talk about ten books I feel pressured to read – by Goodreads ratings! I’d been wanting to do a post like this for a while, so I thought this would be a good opportunity.

I sorted my Goodreads TBR shelf by highest ratings, and then ignored anything unreleased or anything that had less than 100 ratings, just so we could get some pretty “fair” numbers. I also skipped any series duplicates.


1. Words of Radiance — Brandon Sanderson — 4.77 avg
I know Brandon’s works are popular, but I had never realized how highly rated this series is! The first book in the series, The Way of Kings, was also in my top 10, at 4.64!
Ratings: 129,519


2. Godsgrave — Jay Kristoff — 4.59 avg
I 5-starred Nevernight recently (review here), so I wasn’t surprised to see this one make the cut. If you’re wondering, Nevernight‘s average is 4.28, which is still mighty high!
Ratings: 5,492

3. Clockwork Princess — Cassandra Clare — 4.59 avg
I knew The Infernal Devices was popular, but didn’t know it was this popular! This is the 3rd book in the trilogy; if you’re curious, books 1 and 2 got 4.34 and 4.45 respectively.
Ratings: 267,449

4. Queen of Shadows — Sarah J. Maas — 4.59 avg
If I wasn’t skipping series duplicates, this would be the 1st of a few TOG books to make this list – super beloved series right here! This is book #4, and the other books in the series are sitting at:
#1 – 4.23
#2 – 4.48
#3 – 4.52
#5 – 4.58
#6 – 4.47
Ratings: 141,586


5. The Wise Man’s Fear — Patrick Rothfuss — 4.58 avg
I think I would’ve been devastated if this series hadn’t made the top 10 list, with how eager I am to read it! This is book #2 – #1 has a 4.55 avg.
Ratings: 314,176

6. Dear Ijeawele… — Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie — 4.56 avg
This little feminist nonfiction is only 63 pages long, but clearly very beloved, and one that I want to read ASAP!
Ratings: 20,340

7. Saga, Vol 2 — Brian K. Vaughan — 4.56 avg

I like the Saga graphic novel series, but I didn’t expect to see it make the list, honestly! This is #2, as you can see, but the whole series does pretty well:
#1 – 4.23
#3 – 4.55
#4 – 4.46
#5 – 4.43
#6 – 4.49
#7 – 4.52
#8 – 4.45
Ratings: 66,562


8. The House of Hades — Rick Riordan — 4.55 avg
I’m so happy to see this make the list, because I plan on finishing up the PJO series soon and starting this one immediately after! This is book #4, and the other books’ ratings are:
#1 – 4.35
#2 – 4.44
#3 – 4.46
#5 – 4.42
Ratings: 195,316

9. The Nightingale — Kristin Hannah — 4.55 avg
I honestly don’t know why I haven’t bought this book yet, but I should, and soon. It has a great average rating, has won a ton of awards, and is a WWII hist-fic story, which is always a favorite topic of mine (even if it is devastating).
Ratings: 402,062

10. Lord of Shadows — Cassandra Clare — 4.54 avg
I know, another of Cassie’s books, but this is her newest trilogy, so I felt that it was a fair addition to the list, haha! This is #2 in The Dark Artifices; book #1 is sitting at 4.45.
Ratings: 46,434

Have you read any of the books in this list? If so, what star rating did you give them?


Posted by

Just a children's librarian/horror aficionado/geek girl trying to juggle motherhood, grad school, blogging, gaming, and everyday life.

67 thoughts on “T10T: Highest Rated TBR Titles

    1. Thank you so much, Chrissi! Haha, it really can be – while I was making this list, I was like, “Man, maybe I should stop requesting ARCs just so I can read some of these!” and then I had a good, long laugh at myself… 😉 lol! I’m glad you liked The Nightingale – I see it on sale at Books-A-Million all the time when I go, so I think I’ll pick it up next time!


  1. I have read Nevernight and loved it! But I am also yet to read Godsgrave. I own it but have been putting it of. I don’t really know why? Like I know its going to be good that many people can’t be wrong! But can I handle how good its going to be? Or more importantly how will Mr. Kristoff destroy me this time?!


  2. I really liked The Infernal Devices, but the third one was my least favorite haha. I really enjoyed The Heroes of Olympus and the third one is my favorite from that series.

    I feel so pressured to love The Way of Kings and The Name of the Wind (and honestly I think I will?) so that has been putting me off picking them up.


    1. Haha oh nooo! That’s always a bummer when a series finale is the worst one – but I’m glad you enjoyed it overall! And yes, I totally feel you on The Way of Kings and Name of the Wind. I 100% think I’ll love both of them, but sometimes it can be nerve-wracking to pick up such a widely beloved book.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. WOW,an awesom spin on the topic. I feel the pressure, too. Especially with the Brandon Sanderson books, I mean if it has such a great rating it can’t be bad, right?
    Godsgrave was really great but I love that series. However I also feel that with ratings of 2nd, 3rd and so on book in series the the actual rating is a bit baised because the ones who didn’t like the first to give a negative review is less likely to read those books.
    Also it is strange about Queen of shadows being the highets rated in the ToG series,sor me that was the first one that I really didn’t like.
    Great list!

    Here is my TTT: https://fantasyraiders.wordpress.com/2018/05/15/top-ten-tuesday-books-i-didliked-but-glad-i-read/#more-8338


    1. Awww, yay, I’m so glad! Haha I mean, not “glad” that it destroyed you, but glad you love it! ♥ I’m reading City of Glass next and then I’ll finally get to start TDI since I’m going in the author’s recommended order! 🙂


  4. Wow, this was so interesting to read. I’ll be honest even though I love comics I still haven’t read the Saga series. I almost bought volume 1 the other day but ended up putting it back down. I think I might borrow it from the library though because it does seem really popular! I certainly wasn’t surprised to see Sanderson or Riordan on your list!


  5. I’m a huge fan of Saga so I recommend everyone reads then. I relied on Goodreads for some of my post today too but for different reasons 🙂 I’m amazed at how much I use Goodreads but I also find it somewhat scary.


      1. Definitely Queen of Shadows, because I only recently started the ToG series and feel like there is a lot of pressure to catch up! And Lord of Shadows. I bought it when it came out and I still haven’t read it, ha! So much pressure!!!


      2. Hahaha, I feel you love! I swore I wouldn’t buy any of the TDA books until I read all of TMI and TID, but then last Christmas, Lady Midnight went on a flash sale on Amazon for something like $3 for the hardback and I snatched it up! I think now I have all of the Shadowhunters books except LoS and the Codex, so I still gotta grab those before Queen of Air and Darkness releases, unless I haven’t caught up on the other series in time!


  6. Ooh! I’ve actually never heard of any of these – maybe because I don’t pay much attention to Goodreads ratings! Dear Ijeawele is going on my TBR shelf, though… c:


  7. Love your idea. I recently also looked into my Goodreads TBR and sorted by rating and have been trying to read the most highly rated books. I was surprised that one of the poetry books I bought on a whim was rated second highest in my TBR.


      1. Good! ♥ Thank you, love – I have so many reads scheduled for this week but I want to try. Right now I’ve got 4 current reads, plus a buddy read starting tomorrow and another one Friday, plus Sob-a-thon starts tomorrow… sheesh. I dunno, lmao, but I’m gonna TRY!

        Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! I’m about to pick up Crown of Midnight soon and I’m really excited. 🙂 I’m loving the series so far (granted, I’ve only read The Assassin’s Blade and TOG so far, but still, lol!). And I’m so glad you loved HoO! I’m super excited about that series!

      Thanks, love – I’ll check yours out, too! ♥ Happy reading!


  8. Love this topic! Goodreads ratings definitely add to the hype and pressure sometimes. That said, this list does contain a few of my favorites (such as Queen of Shadows) and a lot of books I REALLY want to get to soon, such as Godsgrave or Lord of Shadows.


  9. I’ve actually only read one, which was Clockwork Princess! I gave it a 5 star rating. The Infernal Devices trilogy is really great! I’m about to start on the Dark Artifices trilogy, just as soon as the audio book is available at my library!
    I have been considering diving into Sarah J. Maas’ books for a while, since everyone seems so obsessed with them.


    1. Oh nooo, sorry you weren’t big on HoO! I’m hoping that I will like it but right now I still gotta finish PJO. I talked a BIG game about catching up on Rick’s entire bibliography before 2019, but now it’s almost June and I’ve only read the first 3 PJO books, so… lol, DEFINITELY don’t think that will happen!

      Liked by 1 person

  10. I had seen the covers of the Throne of Glass series, and thaught they were not for me. Then I got the second book in the series as a review copy from the swedish publisher and felt oblighed to read it. And I was totally blown away..! I read the following book in the series right afterwards, and ordered Queen of Shadows in the original language since it hasn’t been translated into Swedish yet.


    1. Yessss, she definitely is a widely beloved author! I think in the circles of the book community I tend to see a lot of, I find that a lot of people really hate her writing (which I can totally understand!), so sometimes I actually forget that the general consensus on her books (on a wider scale) is SO positive!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s