Since this is an anthology, I’ll be splitting the review up by story first, and then give my overall thoughts at the end!
☠️ THE BIRDS OF AZALEA STREET – Nova Ren Suma★★★☆☆
A group of teen girls observe mysterious incidents going on at their creepy neighbor’s house, and decide to investigate.
The prose was very lovely and gave way to some haunting imagery, but overall the story was pretty boring and unmemorable.
☠️ IN THE FOREST DARK AND DEEP – Carrie Ryan ★★★★★
An incredibly twisted Alice in Wonderland retelling about a girl whose mysterious “white rabbit” watches from the woods and commits horrible acts of violence.
Gruesome, creepy, and easily my favorite story of the collection.
☠️ EMMELINE – Cat Winters ★★★☆☆
A young girl hides away in the wreckage of her war-torn home and awaits unsuspecting soldier boys.
Like Nova’s story, it’s a tale with beautiful writing but lackluster events.
☠️ VERSE CHORUS VERSE – Leigh Bardugo ★★★☆☆
When a pop star comes back from treatment after a DUI and hitting a child, her mother notices that something is very different – and very wrong.
This was one of my most anticipated reads in the collection, because I tend to enjoy Leigh’s writing, and as usual, it was beautiful and descriptive, but I found myself tremendously bored and skimmed several bits of this one. I did love the ending’s creep factor, though.
☠️ HIDE-AND-SEEK – Megan Shepherd ★★★★☆
Some legends claim that, when death comes for you, you may challenge him to a game… and if you win, you keep your life.
I really loved the idea behind this story, and thought it was really fun – probably one of the most interesting plots of the collection, for me.
☠️ THE DARK, SCARY PARTS AND ALL – Danielle Paige★☆☆☆☆
Everyone calls Marnie a “monster”, but when the popular boy in school falls for her, the students find out Marnie isn’t the one they should be afraid of.
I found this story to be fairly subpar and was rolling my eyes by the ending of it. It was too trope-y.
☠️ THE FLICKER, THE FINGERS, THE BEAT, THE SIGH – April Genevieve Tucholke ★☆☆☆☆
When a group of teens hit their classmate on the road and leave her for dead, they quickly learn to regret their indecency.
I’m always interested to reach the editor’s contribution in any given anthology, but in this case, it was my next-to-least favorite contribution. It’s essentially Carrie from the bullies’ POV, which just wasn’t a perspective I was interested in ever hearing.
☠️ FAT GIRL WITH A KNIFE – Jonathan Maberry ★★★★☆
It sucks to be the victim of bullying, but there’s a certain satisfaction that comes with turning the tables on your assailants when the world ends.
I cringed when I read the title of this story, but gave it a chance because my mom loved Maberry’s Rot and Ruin series. I actually was pleasantly surprised and found this to be one of the more fun stories in the collection.
☠️ SLEEPLESS – Jay Kristoff ★★★★★
You have to be careful with online relationships, because you never know who’s really on the other side of the screen.
This was another of my faves; Kristoff’s writing is always fun (though his idea of teen text-speak can be a little excessive at times). I loved the twists in this one.
☠️ M – Stefan Bachmann ★★★★☆
M may be blind, but when she walks into a murder scene, she learns she has other senses that may lead her to the killer – if she can get to him before he kills again.
I really enjoyed the idea behind this one, and loved it up until the ending, which fell short for me, hence my giving it 4 stars instead of 5. The writing was beautiful and very descriptive of how horrifying it would be, to be a blind woman stuck in a house with a murderer.
☠️ THE GIRL WITHOUT A FACE – Marie Lu ★★★★☆
The closet was locked from the inside – so how did the girl get in, and why won’t she stop following him?
I personally have a fear of spooky closets that I never outgrew, so the idea behind this one creeped me out a little. Unfortunately, the middle felt a bit slow and less than thrilling, but I loved the ending (and the twist).
☠️ A GIRL WHO DREAMED OF SNOW – McCormick Templeman ★☆☆☆☆
The shaman’s daughter hunts a cure. The brothers hunt the shaman’s daughter. Unknown to both, a more foreboding presence hunts them all…
If I were rating this as a story in a fantasy collection, I might have given it 3 stars, but this didn’t fit Slasher Girls AT ALL. I kept waiting for the “horror” aspect to kick in, but it was really just a weird fantasy story thrown in.
☠️ STITCHES – A.G. Howard ★★★★★
The good book says, “if your eye causes you to sin, cast it out,” and this abusive father is about to learn it the hard way.
I adored this story. It’s gruesome and gory and downright gross, and I enjoyed every moment of it. The ending is poignant and heavy, but still somehow optimistic.
☠️ ON THE I-5 – Kendare Blake ★★★★★
The I-5 truck route is no safe place for a pretty young girl, but what about a girl who feels a supernatural pull to these monsters – and their victims?
I loved the idea that this young girl could sniff out pedophiles and their victims, and take revenge for the poor girls left in dumpsters and forests. There were some tough parts to read, and the ending was predictable, but I thoroughly enjoyed this ending to the collection.
☠️ COLLECTION ★★★★☆
Averaged out, my rating for the collection altogether came to 3.4/5 stars, which I feel comfortable rounding up to a solid 4. While there were some definite misses, if you’re into YA horror, I still think this is an anthology worth picking up.
Oooh, I’m definitely adding this to my TBR! I’m glad you went through story by story, so I know to expect some bad ones, but some very good ones too!
Yaaay! Aw, thank you for saying that. Sometimes I worry about anthologies, that I might bore people by going into each story, so your comment was very reassuring <3
Great review Destiny! I absolutely adored this book since a majority of the stories were fantastic! I’m so glad you loved both “In The Forest Dark and Deep” as well as “Sleepless” since both of those stories were my favorites from the collection! When I Read “In The Forest Dark and Deep” I was honestly looking over my shoulder will reading it was so freaking creepy and I agree that the twist with “Sleepless” was excellent.
The my least favorites were also “The Dark, Scary Parts and All” and “The Flicker, The Fingers, The Beat, The Sigh” like you said the first one was FULL of tropes and I just…hated every moment of it. Tucholke’s was the same but it felt like a rip off of “Carrie” like you mentioned and also “I Know What You Did Last Summer”(if you’ve seen that one!), her story is literally both of those movies combined in a short story and I had a hard time finding the originality!
Sorry for the long comment, I have a lot of feelings on this one because I wish more people would pick it up! Once again, great review! 🙂
Thanks, Heather! Oh man, In the Forest Dark and Deep legitimately creeped me out, too! It was AWESOME. I read it late at night in a mostly dark and quiet house, and that was the perfect setting for it – especially because I live in a fairly woodsy area, lol!
Oh yes, I haven’t seen I Know What You Did Last Summer in ages but you’re right, I 100% see the “inspiration” (lol, air quotes and rolling my eyes a little) there! It just felt so… sigh, I don’t mean to be so negative, but like there was no unique spin thrown on it at all.
Don’t apologize, I love a good long comment to reply to! 😀 I’m always down for a bookish convo (or rant, lol). Thanks again girly <3
Yes, there definitely wasn’t a unique twist in Tucholke’s story and I was expecting a bit more from the author who selected all of the stories for the book!
This is one of my favorite books so I had to rant and rave a little bit! 🙂
Same! I read a lot of anthologies and it’s interesting to me that the editor’s story is quite frequently the one I like the least! Now that I think about it, maybe that’s why they’re editors… and not the main authors lol!
I read this last year and loved it! I totally forgot about the creepy Alice in Wonderland story, which I don’t know how because that’s the story I actually read twice bc I loved it so much! Thinking about giving this another re-read this October if I can fit it in! I just love horror anthologies. Great review! ?
Honestly, thinking about it right now makes me want to reread that story, too, lol! I adore horror anthologies, too. I think probably half of my horror collection, if not more, is comprised of anthologies! Thank you 🙂
Another thing to add… Thanks. 😉 If you have any, I have been wanting to read more short story/anthologies, even poetry. I haven’t read any of those things. I’m horrible, I know!
Haha, yay! Oh, I can definitely send you some recommendations! I love my anthologies. 🙂 Are you looking for horror specifically?
Anything really!! I think horror would be fun since we are moving into Fall and Halloween!
I’ll DM you on twitter tomorrow <3 if you don't hear from me by evening time, remind me, lol!
I read this not too terribly long after it came out, and while I can’t exactly remember what happened in which stories, I feel like I remember agreeing with your reviews of most of the stories! Like Tucholke can paint the most beautiful picture, but nothing ever happens!!!
[…] Starfish ★★★★★ (review) Slasher Girls & Monster Boys ★★★★☆ (review) The Walking Dead, Vol 1 ★★★★★ Saga, Vol 4 ★★★☆☆ Fables, Vol […]
[…] and honestly, quite a few of them aren’t worth your time at all (you can read my review here to see which ones I’m referring to), but there is one story in particular that I’m […]
[…] Howard – added 01.19.17 The thing is, I love Alice retellings, and this author’s story in Slasher Girls was one of my absolute faves… but I just know I’m gonna hate […]
[…] (review here) […]
[…] Slasher Girls & Monster Boys — April Genevieve Tucholke (editor) — review Creep Level: ????? An anthology of twisted and spooky tales from many popular YA […]